Loading...

Journalism as the Fourth Emergency Service

Trauma and Resilience

by Lisa Bradley (Volume editor) Emma Heywood (Volume editor)
©2024 Textbook XX, 258 Pages
Open Access

Summary

Journalists have often been considered the "fourth emergency service". They are first on the scene, alongside paramedics, fi re and police, running towards danger rather than away, and providing independent, veritable and crucial information in the public interest. And yet, unlike frontline workers, little (if any) counselling or training is offered to journalists on how to deal with the horrors they witness, and the trauma they absorb from being at the forefront of human suffering. Further, limited to no training is given to student journalists on how to prepare themselves for trauma, be it from war scenes to the everyday "death knock". New research is demonstrating a rise in post-traumatic stress disorder amongst journalists resulting from the "everyday" trauma they encounter. There is also a noticeable increase in reluctance from new journalists to undertake emotionally distressing assignments. Editors in industry are now calling for educators to invest in curricula that centre around understanding how to cope with distress and trauma, and why work like this is vital to facilitate the work journalists do hold power to account.
This book investigates the cause and effect of trauma reporting on the journalist themselves and provides a toolkit for training journalists and practitioners to build resilience and prepare themselves for trauma. It draws on national and international experiences enabling readers to gain valuable insight into a range of contemporary issues and the contexts in which they may work.
This edited book offers a blend of academic research studies, evidence-based practitioner interviews, and teaching resources drawing on the experiences of journalists and academics nationally and internationally.

In this increasingly complex and challenging world, there is a real need to consider extra mental health support for journalists. This book is a very valuable addition to that debate.
— Ian MacGregor, Editor Emeritus at the Telegraph and Chair of the Society of Editors.
Journalists head towards danger when everyone else is running away. They see things that are the stuff of nightmares. They can be viciously trolled for telling the truth. The work is exciting and important - but there can be a heavy price to pay in trauma that can last a lifetime. This important book is essential reading for journalists and those concerned about their welfare.
— Jonathan Grun, Emeritus Editor, Press Association.
Journalism as the Fourth Emergency Service: Trauma and Resilience is a well-researched and insightful read for anyone wanting to enter the industry. The authors have carefully crafted the perfect guide to navigate new journalists through the new and ever- changing world. Their understanding and acknowledgement of the struggles and difficulties faced by journalists makes for an insightful and honest read about what to expect before entering any newsroom. I wish I had this before becoming a journalist.
— Katie Ridley, Journalist ITV Anglia.
An essential read for journalists at all stages of their career, this book is an invaluable resource for navigating the challenges both in and beyond the newsroom. It provides much- sought- after guidance that reporters have been yearning for, blending research- based insights with actionable advice - and will be beneficial for trainees and seasoned professionals alike.
— Harriet Rose Gale, Head of Features (Digital and Print), SWNS Media Group.

Table Of Contents

  • Cover
  • Titel
  • Copyright
  • Autorenangaben
  • Über das Buch
  • Zitierfähigkeit des eBooks
  • Table of Contents
  • List of Figures
  • List of Tables
  • Foreword
  • Acknowledgements
  • List of Abbreviations/Glossary
  • Introduction
  • Journalism as an Emergency Service and the Psychological Impact
  • Emergency Frontline Workers Offer Five Lessons for Journalist Wellbeing
  • News Feature: Rachael Venables: “There is life outside the trauma”
  • First Hand Trauma
  • News Feature: Rory Carroll: “I wasn’t traumatised. It was the job and it was what I had signed up for”
  • Writing as Balm: Humanitarian Journalism, “Body 422”, and the Infliction and Transformation of Trauma
  • Perceived Organisational Support After a Traumatic Event: A Case Study of How Slovak Newsrooms Coped with the Murder of Investigative Journalist Ján Kuciak
  • Covering the Climate-Induced Flooding in Pakistan: Causes, Effects, and Outcomes of Journalistic Ordeals
  • The Hidden Threat: Journalism and Resilience in the Age of Information Disorder
  • Local Journalists and Trauma in Burkina Faso
  • News Feature: Vivienne Aitken: “These things had not happened to us. Who were we to say we wanted counselling?”
  • Vicarious Trauma
  • News Feature: Looking the Devil in the Eye: How Three Reporters Coped with Covering the “most harrowing trial in fifty years” of Child Serial Killer Lucy Letby
  • “Putting up the bulletproof glass”: The Impact of Court Reporting on Working Journalists in the UK
  • The Death Knock as Emotional Labour—Reframing a “rite of passage” to Help Journalists Cope
  • Teaching Reporting on Death: Thanatology and Death Education as Tools to Prepare Journalists for Vicarious Trauma
  • Don’t Be a Jerk: Guidelines for Ethical and Sustainable Collaboration among Reporters, Fixers, and Local Producers Covering Warzones
  • News Feature: David Ward: “I hang onto my belief in human kindness”
  • Cyber Environment and Abuse
  • News Feature: Leona O’Neill: “I am not the same person anymore”
  • “An emotional flak jacket”: Helping Journalism Students to Stay Resilient and Safe Online
  • Building Resilience against SLAPPs: Protecting Investigative Journalists and Students from Traumatic Legal Threats
  • Creating a Workplace Culture
  • Gender and Diversity
  • Rethinking “Hostile” Environments: Toward Trauma Literacy and Identity-Aware Safety Training for Journalists
  • Encouraging Reporting of Sexual Harassment by Journalists
  • The Education Environment
  • News Feature: Chris Elliott: “If you are triggered by trauma, then there is a need to consider if journalism is the right job for you”
  • “They definitely throw you in the deep end”—a UK Graduate Perspective on Journalism Practice
  • Effective Ways to Teach Trauma and Resilience to Journalists
  • “All Rise”: Immersive Dramatic Performance Techniques to Build Resilience in Trainee Court Reporters
  • Further Multimedia and Online Resources You Might Find Useful
  • Notes on Contributors
  • Index

List of Tables

Table 23.1 Percentages and Ns of specific sexual harassment behaviours (150 total journalists)

Table 23.2 Perpetrators of journalists’ most distressing sexual harassment experience (150 total journalists)

Table 23.3 Reasons for not reporting sexual harassment (126 total journalists)

Foreword

Jo Healey

Do your job, do it well, do no harm…

Across thirty years as a journalist, I have interviewed hundreds of people whose lives and emotions have been shattered, as have many journalists. However, we are rarely taught how to go about it. Our industry tradition is that we effectively, or not, practise on the grieving public. We barely give a thought to the effect this work may be having on us.

“We’re not psychologists, we’re not counsellors and we’re not trained and we’re asking them to relive horrific moments in their lives,” says TV reporter Simon Hare.

For several years, I have been training journalists globally in how best to work with victims and survivors and how to look after themselves as they go about these emotionally tough assignments.

Whether covering harrowing court cases, hearing horrific accounts, or witnessing tragedies first hand or via graphic imagery, journalists may be impacted. They cannot unsee or unhear this stuff.

Vicious online abuse, cuts in newsroom budgets, and intensifying pressure to deliver material to multiple platforms all add to the mix.

“No story is worth a person’s mental health or a person’s life, not yours and not theirs either,” says BBC Paris Correspondent Lucy Williamson.

That is why this much-needed book is so important. It offers clear insight into why and how journalists may be affected by the stories they may be covering daily, from war zones to court rooms and just about everything in between. However, it does not shy away from the journalist’s mission to report and deliver.

Edited by Lisa Bradley and Emma Heywood, Journalism as the Fourth Emergency Service: Trauma and Resilience deep dives into the key issues for journalists covering trauma and distress. It not only shares invaluable insight from a raft of experts but also provides a wealth of important advice in the form of tips, talking points, and tasks for students and teachers alike. The innovative form of the book, as a “hybrid” academic-textbook, has something to offer everyone, from those researching trauma and journalism to those preparing to become journalists and those already in the field.

I have been lucky enough to work with some of Lisa and Emma’s journalism students at the University of Sheffield and to witness first-hand the progressive nature of their work in this growing field of trauma reporting.

In my training sessions, countless working journalists shared how much they wished they had been taught the basics of trauma reporting while at university, particularly how best to approach people at emotionally sensitive times and how to go about interviewing them.

As journalists, we are geared towards reflecting other people’s lives, and we forget that we too need some self-reflection and care. As the book points out, along with emergency responders, we can run towards the danger that others are fleeing, and this can take its toll on us.

BBC Middle East Editor Jeremy Bowen is a veteran of scores of international conflicts, wars, disasters and humanitarian crises. “The cost of spending years going to places where you see the best of humanity as well as the worst of humanity you do eventually pay some kind of price, and that’s why you need to be aware of your mental health, deal with things as they arise, talk always, share with your colleagues. Do not bottle it up,” he told me.

From attacks to abuse to lost homes, lost health, lost livelihoods and lost lives, we often tell our stories best through the people they affect. However, that can mean that so many journalists may be dealing regularly and closely with people who are suffering but who choose to share their painful experiences. It can be a relentless part of the job both in regular and conflict reporting.

Journalists need to know how to do this work well, know how it may affect them and their colleagues, and know what to do about it before, during and after the assignments. This book will enlighten and support them while hopefully making them better journalists.

Jo Healey, Author of Trauma Reporting, A Journalist’s Guide to Covering Sensitive Stories.

Acknowledgements

We would firstly like to thank the wonderful authors who have contributed to this book and without whom it would not have been possible. They have been a joy to work with and their advice and expertise throughout the process has been invaluable.

We would also like to thank Lizzie Howard at Peter Lang, our editor, for guiding us through the publication process. It has been a pleasure and her efficient but lighthearted way of working with us has definitely made editing a volume on trauma less traumatic, also to Niall Kennedy, for commissioning us before he upped sticks and left for pastures new—but who had such fantastic vision for the book. We are very grateful.

Our thanks also go to the many unnamed friends and colleagues who have helped and supported us. Our particular thanks go to our families—Mark, Tommy and Oscar on Lisa’s side, and John, Mollie, Rory and Ted on Emma’s.

But mostly, our dogs.

List of Abbreviations/Glossary

Death knocksThe practice of knocking on the door of a bereaved family to obtain an interview
DSM-VDiagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders—a taxonomic and diagnostic tool published by the American Psychiatric Association
Emotional labourThe process of managing emotional responses to meet the requirements of a job (Hoschschild, 1979). Hopper and Huxford define it as “the suppression of personal, emotional identity for the sake of an ideologically driven, detached professional self” (2015, p. 38).
HEFATHostile Environment and First Aid Training
Information disorderFirst Draft defines information disorder as a collective noun for false information that is shared either with or without intent. Hence, disinformation, misinformation and mal-information can be termed collectively as “information disorder”. For more detail see: <https://firstdraftnews.org/long-form-article/understanding-information-disorder/> (see chapter by Fowler-Watt et al.)
Information ecosystemThe information ecosystem is understood to be complex adaptive systems that include information infrastructure, tools, media, producers, consumers, curators, and sharers. They are complex organisations of dynamic social relationships through which information moves and transforms in flows.
Information warInformation war can be defined as the use of information to achieve national objectives. According to NATO, information war can be waged to gain an information advantage over the opponent (see chapter by Fowler-Watt et al.)
IWMFInternational Women’s Media Foundation
Moral compassA personal set of beliefs and values regarding right and wrong
Moral injuryA moral injury may occur when a person witnesses or participates in an event, which strongly conflicts with that person’s morals, i.e. one’s core beliefs and expectations about the nature of the world, particularly regarding how other persons and oneself ought to behave. Moral injury can arise where sustained moral distress leads to impaired function or longer-term psychological harm.
MSMMainstream media
NCTJNational Council for the Training of Journalists (UK)
NGONon-governmental organisation
NUJNational Union of Journalists (UK)
Psychological resilienceThe ability to cope mentally and emotionally with a crisis, or to return to pre-crisis status quickly
PTSDPost traumatic stress disorder
SLAPPsStrategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation
SRASolicitors Regulation Authority
STSSecondary traumatic stress, or STS, like PTSD produces flashbacks, desensitisation, numbness, a heightened responses to perceived dangers, but is experienced not by the person to whom the trauma has occurred, but by the person hearing about it
Vicarious traumaVicarious trauma is the indirect exposure to a traumatic event through first-hand account or narrative of that event. It can trigger a change in how the affected person views the world and their core beliefs about themselves and other people

The material in this book contains images and descriptions of violence, death, trauma, and other triggering events. This content has been included in order to exemplify, support, and clarify the arguments in the chapters. Readers who might find this material upsetting or may be sensitive to these issues please take note.

CHAPTER 1

Introduction

Emma Heywood and Lisa Bradley

Trauma in journalism is not a new phenomenon. From the battlefields to the city streets, humanitarian crises to the courtrooms, trauma has plagued the profession whether directly or indirectly, vicariously or through lived experience, since the ink dried on the first newspaper sheets in 1566.

A systematic review of studies conducted between 2010 and 2022 revealed significant numbers of journalists who reported either PTSD, PTSD symptoms, depression, and/or substance use (Flannery, 2022). Whilst it could be expected that these journalists would include war reporters and foreign correspondents given the nature of their job, it also includes “lower level” reporters whose jobs are perhaps not perceived as being so glamorous, but who cover, day in day out, the epitome of human misery. The build-up of this work-related trauma has long been considered to be just part of the job, but the increasing numbers of those leaving the industry because of mental health disorders (MHD) or associated medical conditions, to say nothing of new starters resigning after being forced to watch graphic videos just days into the job, all point to a broken, or even non-existent, support system that we can no longer ignore. If journalism, an essential and key part of democracy, is to be preserved, this darker side of the industry must be addressed.

Journalism has been called the fourth emergency service, rushing towards the danger rather than away. Unlike the fire, police and ambulance services, however, the role of a journalist is not to provide immediate help but rather to observe and report. An inaction that some would say is traumatic in itself (Osofsky et al., 2005; Osmann et al., 2021). However, journalists suffer in similar ways to the emergency services, witnessing the same horrors and victims (Cote & Simpson, 2000), but are additionally affected by their inability to act and provide direct help immediately. Moreover, unlike the emergency services, counselling or mental health support is not routinely offered to journalists.

The demand for trauma training is now at the forefront of the industry debate. In the UK, the National Council of Training for Journalists (NCTJ) has included safety and resilience in its accreditation requirements for training centres for 2024. This means that all journalism training courses that intend to deliver the NCTJ diploma must demonstrate how they educate their students in trauma literacy, resilience and safety awareness, both physically and mentally. The aim is to equip the next generation of journalists for the ever-growing harsh realities they face, as an increasing number of journalists work remotely, or hybrid, without the camaraderie or immediate support from senior and other journalists. Trauma is no longer seen as “just part of the job”; instead, there is an emerging recognition from newsrooms that reporters need to learn how to take care of themselves and their own mental health to do the job to the best of their ability.

And this starts in the classroom.

What Is Trauma?

The debate about trauma and its impact on journalists has been gaining attention over recent decades, and a substantial body of literature already exists concerning the psychological and emotional effects that journalists are exposed to as a result of work-related stressors. The Dart Centre (2007) makes the distinction between stressful and traumatic incidents, defining trauma as follows:

Details

Pages
XX, 258
Publication Year
2024
ISBN (PDF)
9781636671987
ISBN (ePUB)
9781636671994
ISBN (Softcover)
9781636672007
DOI
10.3726/b21650
Open Access
CC-BY
Language
English
Publication date
2024 (April)
Keywords
Trauma journalism moral injury emotional load stressors trauma training resilience self-care education Lisa Bradley Emma Heywood Trauma and Resilience Journalism as the Fourth Emergency Service
Published
New York, Berlin, Bruxelles, Chennai, Lausanne, Oxford, 2024. XX, 258 pp., 15 b/w ill., 3 tables.

Biographical notes

Lisa Bradley (Volume editor) Emma Heywood (Volume editor)

Lisa Bradley is an award-winning journalist, lecturer and novelist. She was a crime and campaign reporter nationally and regionally for 20 years and is now Deputy Head of the School of Journalism, Media and Communication at the University of Sheffield. Dr Emma Heywood is a Senior Lecturer and researcher in the School of Journalism, Media and Communication at the University of Sheffield. She has extensive experience of investigating radio journalism in-the-field in conflict-affected areas and in humanitarian settings, particularly relating to women’s empowerment.

Previous

Title: Journalism as the Fourth Emergency Service